Welcome to Reyes Bakery
At Reyes Bakery, we celebrate the rich tapestry of Mexican flavors through our delectable treats. Nestled in Appleton, WI, our bakery is a haven for those who cherish the joy of baked goods. Indulge in a vast selection of artisanal cupcakes, large muffins, and traditional pastries like Conchas and Mantecadas—all crafted with love and authenticity. Each bite encapsulates our passion for baking and our commitment to quality. Whether you dine in, take out, or enjoy delivery, Reyes Bakery invites you to savor the delightful experience of sweet creations that evoke the warmth of home. Feel the love in every flavor!
- 2305 S Oneida St Appleton, WI 54915 United States Hotline: (920) 830-7970
Welcome to Reyes Bakery, a delightful haven for cupcake aficionados and lovers of Mexican treats, nestled in the heart of Appleton, Wisconsin. This charming bakery at 2305 S Oneida St beckons you with the warm aromas of freshly baked goods, inviting you to embark on a culinary adventure that promises both sweetness and satisfaction.
Reyes Bakery stands out not only for its scrumptious cupcakes, but also for its extensive selection of authentic Mexican pastries. The flavors are a vibrant reflection of culinary artistry, crafted with passion and precision. Here are some highlights from their tantalizing menu:
- Mantecada: A fluffy muffin in multiple flavors, perfect for a morning treat.
- Conchas: Iconic Mexican sweet breads with a colorful topping, available in assorted flavors.
- Beso: Indulgent Bavarian cream-filled pastries that melt in your mouth.
- Borracho: A delicious strawberry pastry dusted with sugar—a must-try for fruit lovers.
- Croissants: Choose between plain or cheese for a flaky, buttery delight.
- Flan: A creamy custard dessert that offers both traditional and chocolate variations, leaving a lingering sweetness.
Beyond pastries, Reyes Bakery makes enjoying your treats even easier with convenient options for delivery and takeout. You can savor their offerings from anywhere, making it a fantastic choice for a cozy night in or a picnicking adventure. Plus, they accept credit cards, adding to the overall ease of your experience.
Each bite at Reyes Bakery is a celebration—a joyous experience crafted from high-quality ingredients and rich cultural heritage. The ambiance is welcoming, the staff is friendly, and the variety of flavors ensures that there’s something for everyone. Whether you’re a local resident or just passing through Appleton, make sure to stop by Reyes Bakery and indulge in their heavenly cupcakes and inspired Mexican treats. Your taste buds will thank you!
For more information or to place an order, feel free to call them at (920) 830-7970. Don’t miss the chance to experience the bliss that awaits at Reyes Bakery.

Well worth the 2 hour drive! Excellent Bakery

When the very sweet and polite cashier told me my total I was genuinely confused. 3.90 for 3 large pastry items that tasted amazing and fresh! Amazing how low the prices are with such fantastic quality! We will be making this our only stop for muffins or sweets.

This is our familys favorite Mexican bakery. They have truly authentic Mexican pasteries some of our favorites include Conchas Canones. They speak fluent Spanish and have authentic Mexican store items too, such as candies. ...

Great prices. Friendly staff. This is my goto place for my families birthday cakes. The tres leches cakes are amazing and the nontres leches cakes are not too sweet like the cakes that most other bakeries offer. I also enjoy coming here ...

Very nice people. They have a good variety of baked goods along with other packaged treats. Its very well priced. We will certainly be going back!

Excellent bakery in the fox valley area. We used to visit another hispanic bakery, but we found these one that has more sweet bread variety and also cheaper prices. Once in a while a rude person is attending in front, but for the most part the girls upfront are very nice and helpful.

Not your typical American bakery. I have often found myself looking over the cases of bakery delights while doing my laundry next door. The prices are great for what you get, and the staff are friendly and helpful. You would do well to know ...

To be honest, I have no idea what half of the pastries are... But they looked delicious, and Im going to need to try every one, because the conchas were delicious.